BLACK+DECKER 17 Cu. Ft. Convertible Best Overall
- Energy
- ENERGY STAR qualified
- Defrost
- Frost-free
- Capacity
- 17 cubic feet
- Dimensions
- 31.9"D x 28"W x 68.1"H
Frost-free is the reason this one leads. Every other freezer in this guide is a manual-defrost box, which means a scraper, a towel, and an afternoon a few times a year — the chore that comes up again and again on the manual models here. The BLACK+DECKER handles its own defrost cycle, so the only upkeep left is wiping down a shelf. It also carries the most capacity in this group, 17 cubic feet across four glass shelves you can read without crouching, with an LED control instead of a dial.
The convertible side is more useful than it sounds. Drop the cabinet into refrigerator range and 17 cubic feet becomes the overflow fridge for a holiday, a graduation party, or a basement bar, and the electronic control turns that into a button press rather than a dial-and-guess. It is rated for garage use as well, which matters when the unit lives next to the car and the temperature outside drops.
Two practical checks before you order. The door is right-hinged only — every other pick here lets you flip the hinge — so work out which side the freezer will sit against. At 165 pounds, this is a two-person delivery into a spot you have already cleared. Then put a thermometer inside for the first week: we want to know where the interior actually sits before a hundred pounds of meat goes in, because the readout and the cabinet can drift a few degrees apart.
It is the wrong buy for a studio or a two-person household topping up a fridge; a 3-cubic-foot box does that job with a fraction of the floor. What the extra size and money buy is the end of defrosting and enough volume for a quarter of beef, and most families with a spare garage corner will take that trade.
What We Like
- Frost-free cabinet, so no manual defrosting
- 17 cubic feet on see-through glass shelves
- Converts to a full-size refrigerator
- ENERGY STAR qualified and garage rated
Worth Noting
- Right-hinged door only; check the swing side
- 165 pounds, so plan a two-person delivery
We recommend this one to any household that wants a second freezer without a defrost ritual: 17 cubic feet, frost-free, ENERGY STAR rated, and a fridge mode when you need it.
Check Latest Price